See

Why

Parobyte Technologies upto

Parobyte Technologies upto

You can get feedback like this for free in our app

You can get feedback like this for free in our app

See Why

YC Application Feedback

YC Application Feedback

See Why is an AI tool designed to help you understand why your YC application may have been rejected and what you can do to improve it. By analyzing YC content and top applications, See Why provides actionable feedback, helping you refine your application for better chances of success.

How See Why Can Help You

  • Identify Weaknesses: Understand the specific areas where your application falls short.

  • Actionable Insights: Receive clear, practical advice on how to improve your application.

  • Continuous Improvement: Discover opportunities for ongoing enhancement to stay competitive.

Unsuccessful

YC Application Feedback

YC Application Feedback

Company

Describe what your company does in 50 characters or less.

Our 2-hr supply prevents stockouts at small stores.

What is your company going to make? Please describe your product and what it does or will do.

We are building a platform for Corner Stores to search and order SKUs that are stocked-out at the time and get them delivered in <2 hours. It works on an asset light model with partner warehouses and partner logistics. Our tools would optimize SKU assortment, warehousing, and logistics. Our product will help in preventing the 15% sales loss that corner stores suffer due to stock outs.

Where do you live now, and where would the company be based after YC?

Bangalore, India

Founders

Please tell us about an interesting project, preferably outside of class or work, that two or more of you created together. Include urls if possible.

We decided to start-up together after one of us - Abhijit decided to solve a crucial problem that he faced during his first job in a big government power company.

At the time, the company was using archaic methods to layout the expansion plan of new transmission lines across multiple regions. They brought together data from multiple tools such as AutoCAD, Excel sheets, Garmin GPS, and Google Earth geolocation data, which were painstakingly collected through ground surveys. No application was available that could do interoperability of these tools. This had to be done manually by copying and pasting from one tool to another. On top of it, google APIs were available to get the elevation data along a line.

Observing this opportunity, Abhijit roped in Muneeb and created a desktop application that helped in interoperability of these tools and extraction of elevation data. A downloadable product with a licensing fee was launched. After realizing that the product could be also sold to construction industry, I joined the firm in 2014.We sold the product to 10+ land survey firms, generating a total revenue of 1m INR (US $15k).

We could not scale further as there were only a handful of power and construction firms in India and many big ones had internally developed tools that they were not willing to move away from.

How long have the founders known one another and how did you meet? Have any of the founders not met in person?

We did our undergrad in engineering in the same university and graduated together. We know one another for around a decade after first meeting in our college dorm.

How many founders are on the team?

3

Category

Which category best applies to your company?

Retail

Progress

How far along are you?

We have launched the product. We have 100 paying customers as of now and we get 40 orders per day. This is in just a single locality in Bangalore. As of now, we are not operating warehouses. As and when we get the orders, our team members who would be at the nearby Metro Cash n Carry, procure the products and hand them over to 3rd party logistics riders for them to deliver. The current average order value is ~65 USD and cost of fulfilment is ~1.2 USD.

How long have each of you been working on this? How much of that has been full-time? Please explain.

We have been working on tools for Corner Stores since Dec’20 and pivoted to this product in May’21. Two of us are working full time on this since then - 2.5 months. Abhijith has started full time from June end.

Are people using your product?

Yes

How many active users or customers do you have? If you have some particularly valuable customers, who are they? If you're building hardware, how many units have you shipped?

We have 100+ customers all located in and around Whitefield, Bangalore.

Our valuable customers are the ones who do >4 orders per week in the platform. The AOV is ~100 USD for these customers. The good thing about these customers is that they have started using our platform for regular procurement that are outside of stocked out SKUs.

Do you have revenue?

Yes

We're interested in your revenue over the last several months. (Not cumulative and not GMV).

  • What was your revenue in June? $20,000

  • What was your revenue in May? $450

  • What was your revenue in April? $

  • What was your revenue in March? $0

  • What was your revenue in February? $0

  • What was your revenue in January? $0

Anything else you would like us to know regarding your revenue or growth rate?

We are growing at a tremendous pace, and we are set to reach USD 50k in revenue in July’21. Our model is hyperlocal in nature. This growth has been achieved by operating in just a locality of Bangalore. We are planning to add more localities in the city and reach 5,000 customers by end of 2021 and reach a monthly revenue of ~$ 1 million per month.

If you are applying with the same idea as a previous batch, did anything change? If you applied with a different idea, why did you pivot and what did you learn from the last idea?

We pivoted. Our first product - ClearBook was a bookkeeping android app for the small stores to accurately track profit and cash in hand. We grew this app to 5,000 downloads and 200 DAU with zero marketing spend.

However, after spending time with around 200+ customers of ClearBook in Bangalore, we understood that frequent stock-outs are a bigger problem for the stores. This leads to revenue loss and at times, even customer churn. Although this problem is more operationally complex to solve, it is a bigger pain point for them, and the solution is also monetizable from day 1.

If you have already participated or committed to participate in an incubator, "accelerator" or "pre-accelerator" program, please tell us about it.

Na

Idea

Why did you pick this idea to work on? Do you have domain expertise in this area? How do you know people need what you're making?

In 2018, as an investment to get additional income, all three of us with a couple of others, invested in a pharmacy store in Bangalore. As we ran into many bookkeeping problems in the store, Muneeb created a simple android app for the store staff to track daily revenue and expenses. The app - ClearBook was published in Play Store, grew to 5,000 downloads and 200 DAU with zero marketing spend.

This made us to spend time with around 100+ corner stores (who were ClearBook customers) in Bangalore. We noticed that almost all of them ran out of stocks of a few SKUs almost every day. In multiple times per week, we could see the store operators rushing to nearby wholesale markets to refill stocks for the stocked-out SKUs. No distributor or B2B ecommerce company delivered products on the same day. Some distributors took even more than a week for delivery.

We volunteered a few times to go to wholesale market to procure the products for a store operator on his behalf. And after helping him on this for a few times, we imagined that we could deliver products to all stores and create a business out of it. We found that Corner stores lose ~15% sales because of stock outs. This is because of lack of digital billing system and tracking of inventory, shortage of space to put excess inventory and lack of working capital. This problem could be solved by multiple small warehouses in a city with optimized SKU assortment, inventory, and logistics. That is how we decided launch Angadi.

We believe that we are the right team to do this. All 3 of us have a passion for retail and have known one another for around a decade. I have managed a $50 million distribution company with a reach to 100,000 small stores. Abhijit has 10+ years in tech and was the Director of Engineering at a major fintech player, with a strong understanding of credit & loan in retail. Muneeb is a CS grad and has developed multiple products for Retailers and Small Businesses during his career.

What's new about what you're making? What substitutes do people resort to because it doesn't exist yet (or they don't know about it)?

There is no distributor/company in the market that supplies to the stores within the same day, let alone in 2 hours. As of now, the only substitute that the stores have for stocked out products - is to go to the nearby wholesale market/distributor and get the stock replenished by themselves. Else, they suffer sales loss till the time the stock is delivered by a distributor; this is typically between 2 days and 1 week.

Who are your competitors, and who might become competitors? Who do you fear most?

Udaan, Amazon Business and Flipkart B2B, among others, are our competitors. These companies have a slightly different value proposition. They provide the broadest selection at the cheapest prices. We, on the other hand, provide a selection of fast-moving SKUs with fastest delivery.

We fear firms with deep market penetration such as Udaan and Amazon Business. Even though they have evolved as B2B ecommerce firms with a big fulfilment centre per region, it is not impossible for them to add multiple small FCs within in the region/city to cut down on the fulfilment time.

What do you understand about your business that other companies in it just don't get?

- For 85% of all procurement, the corner stores would check with all the suppliers - Open Market Distributors, Udaan, Amazon Business, Flipkart Wholesale etc before making the order. The procurement decision is then made by the retailers after considering just one factor – who gives lowest price? There is almost zero loyalty for retailers to any supplier here.

- The remaining 15% procurement kicks in, when there is a stockout. For this, stores do either of below:

Roughly ~50% Corner Store owners rush to a nearby wholesale markets to get the products in cash.

And the remaining half decide to suffer sales loss for next 2 days. They make an order in any of the apps/distributors and get the orders in due time albeit suffering the loss in sales (and more importantly customer satisfaction) in the interim period.

- The procurement decision for this “15%” is unique. Retailers are willing to go through the inconvenience, pay in cash for the order and in a few cases willing to pay a small premium for some products. Almost all the companies focus on “85%” market and there is no one that is solving the “15%” problem.

- This “15%” procurement is done for FMCG products. These products have relatively higher margin compared to commodities (sacks of rice, sugar, wheat etc) that retailers plan and purchase.

- The order size of B2C consumer delivery apps such as Instamart (of Swiggy), Flipkart Quick and Amazon Fresh is ~ $6. Our AOV is ~ $65 that could be achieved at the same SKU collection in the warehouse and fulfilled at almost the same delivery expense. And there is more opportunity to become a sole supplier of our valuable customers in due time.

How do or will you make money? How much could you make?

We make money from the margin of the goods that we sell to the corner stores. As of now, we are keeping this as an inventory model with stock in the partner warehouses.

Small stores account for ~90% of total Indian grocery market of $ 800 billion. Our addressable market size is 15% of it – $120 billion dollars. Our plan is to onboard around 1 million retailers by 2025. At an average order size of $6,500 dollars per retailer per year – we could reach a revenue of $6.5 billion.

How will you get users? If your idea is the type that faces a chicken-and-egg problem in the sense that it won't be attractive to users till it has a lot of users (e.g. a marketplace, a dating site, an ad network), how will you overcome that?

We have grown to 100+ users as now. 60+ stores were onboarded by meeting and signing up them when they visited Metro CashNCarry for their purchases. We offered them the same price as that of Metro at zero delivery fees. The rest 40 were added by these customers through referrals. All 100 stores are within a locality of 3 km radius.

It is evident that a large fraction of small store operators would require 1-1 onboarding to start using B2B ecommerce apps. Hence, our plan is to grow users through a mix of 1-1 onboarding, referral campaigns and tie up with bookkeeping apps with high penetration to add more users. We do not have a chicken-and-egg problem.

Equity

Have you incorporated, or formed any legal entity (like an LLC) yet?

Yes

What kind of entity and in what state or country was the entity formed?

Private Limited Company

Please describe the breakdown of the equity ownership in percentages among the founders, employees and any other stockholders. If there are multiple founders, be sure to give the equity ownership of each founder.

We have split equally (33.33% each)

Please provide any other relevant information about the structure or formation of the company.

NA

Legal

Are any of the founders covered by noncompetes or intellectual property agreements that overlap with your project? If so, please explain.

No

Who writes code, or does other technical work on your product? Was any of it done by a non-founder? Please explain.

Both Abhijit and Muneeb write the code.

Is there anything else we should know about your company?

NA

Others

If you had any other ideas you considered applying with, please list them. One may be something we've been waiting for. Often when we fund people it's to do something they list here and not in the main application.

SMB investment marketplace - it is extremely difficult for a small business in India to raise equity investment. Also, individuals with dispensable income are unable to invest in small businesses because of lack of information. We intend solve this problem by resolving this information asymmetry and bringing together small to businesses and small investors.

Please tell us something surprising or amusing that one of you has discovered.

In my eleventh grade, I (Jeff) used to toy with various equations in physics. Out of the blue, I decided to equate the RHS of Einstein's mass energy equivalence (E = mc2) and Plank's equation (E=hv). I ended up getting an equation: λ = h/mc. Without knowing much on what the equation would mean, I thought that it connected mass and wavelength in some way.

Just a few months later, I ended up realizing in 12th grade that this is actually the de Broglie's equation on wave particle duality and the equation was derived in pretty much the same way. Although, it meant that I wasn't the first discoverer of wave particle duality, I did invariably come up with the concept unbeknownst to me that this is something that all physicists knew for many years. A discovery that I'm still proud of :)

Curious

What convinced you to apply to Y Combinator? Did someone encourage you to apply?

YC is the ideal next step for us use the exposure and knowledge that we could get from the program to scale our product and make our startup a success.

We have been following YC podcasts and have a pretty good understanding of the program and how it will help us to succeed.

How did you hear about Y Combinator?

We have been following YC Podcasts/Hacker News for quite some time.

Company

Describe what your company does in 50 characters or less.

Our 2-hr supply prevents stockouts at small stores.

What is your company going to make? Please describe your product and what it does or will do.

We are building a platform for Corner Stores to search and order SKUs that are stocked-out at the time and get them delivered in <2 hours. It works on an asset light model with partner warehouses and partner logistics. Our tools would optimize SKU assortment, warehousing, and logistics. Our product will help in preventing the 15% sales loss that corner stores suffer due to stock outs.

Where do you live now, and where would the company be based after YC?

Bangalore, India

Founders

Please tell us about an interesting project, preferably outside of class or work, that two or more of you created together. Include urls if possible.

We decided to start-up together after one of us - Abhijit decided to solve a crucial problem that he faced during his first job in a big government power company.

At the time, the company was using archaic methods to layout the expansion plan of new transmission lines across multiple regions. They brought together data from multiple tools such as AutoCAD, Excel sheets, Garmin GPS, and Google Earth geolocation data, which were painstakingly collected through ground surveys. No application was available that could do interoperability of these tools. This had to be done manually by copying and pasting from one tool to another. On top of it, google APIs were available to get the elevation data along a line.

Observing this opportunity, Abhijit roped in Muneeb and created a desktop application that helped in interoperability of these tools and extraction of elevation data. A downloadable product with a licensing fee was launched. After realizing that the product could be also sold to construction industry, I joined the firm in 2014.We sold the product to 10+ land survey firms, generating a total revenue of 1m INR (US $15k).

We could not scale further as there were only a handful of power and construction firms in India and many big ones had internally developed tools that they were not willing to move away from.

How long have the founders known one another and how did you meet? Have any of the founders not met in person?

We did our undergrad in engineering in the same university and graduated together. We know one another for around a decade after first meeting in our college dorm.

How many founders are on the team?

3

Category

Which category best applies to your company?

Retail

Progress

How far along are you?

We have launched the product. We have 100 paying customers as of now and we get 40 orders per day. This is in just a single locality in Bangalore. As of now, we are not operating warehouses. As and when we get the orders, our team members who would be at the nearby Metro Cash n Carry, procure the products and hand them over to 3rd party logistics riders for them to deliver. The current average order value is ~65 USD and cost of fulfilment is ~1.2 USD.

How long have each of you been working on this? How much of that has been full-time? Please explain.

We have been working on tools for Corner Stores since Dec’20 and pivoted to this product in May’21. Two of us are working full time on this since then - 2.5 months. Abhijith has started full time from June end.

Are people using your product?

Yes

How many active users or customers do you have? If you have some particularly valuable customers, who are they? If you're building hardware, how many units have you shipped?

We have 100+ customers all located in and around Whitefield, Bangalore.

Our valuable customers are the ones who do >4 orders per week in the platform. The AOV is ~100 USD for these customers. The good thing about these customers is that they have started using our platform for regular procurement that are outside of stocked out SKUs.

Do you have revenue?

Yes

We're interested in your revenue over the last several months. (Not cumulative and not GMV).

  • What was your revenue in June? $20,000

  • What was your revenue in May? $450

  • What was your revenue in April? $

  • What was your revenue in March? $0

  • What was your revenue in February? $0

  • What was your revenue in January? $0

Anything else you would like us to know regarding your revenue or growth rate?

We are growing at a tremendous pace, and we are set to reach USD 50k in revenue in July’21. Our model is hyperlocal in nature. This growth has been achieved by operating in just a locality of Bangalore. We are planning to add more localities in the city and reach 5,000 customers by end of 2021 and reach a monthly revenue of ~$ 1 million per month.

If you are applying with the same idea as a previous batch, did anything change? If you applied with a different idea, why did you pivot and what did you learn from the last idea?

We pivoted. Our first product - ClearBook was a bookkeeping android app for the small stores to accurately track profit and cash in hand. We grew this app to 5,000 downloads and 200 DAU with zero marketing spend.

However, after spending time with around 200+ customers of ClearBook in Bangalore, we understood that frequent stock-outs are a bigger problem for the stores. This leads to revenue loss and at times, even customer churn. Although this problem is more operationally complex to solve, it is a bigger pain point for them, and the solution is also monetizable from day 1.

If you have already participated or committed to participate in an incubator, "accelerator" or "pre-accelerator" program, please tell us about it.

Na

Idea

Why did you pick this idea to work on? Do you have domain expertise in this area? How do you know people need what you're making?

In 2018, as an investment to get additional income, all three of us with a couple of others, invested in a pharmacy store in Bangalore. As we ran into many bookkeeping problems in the store, Muneeb created a simple android app for the store staff to track daily revenue and expenses. The app - ClearBook was published in Play Store, grew to 5,000 downloads and 200 DAU with zero marketing spend.

This made us to spend time with around 100+ corner stores (who were ClearBook customers) in Bangalore. We noticed that almost all of them ran out of stocks of a few SKUs almost every day. In multiple times per week, we could see the store operators rushing to nearby wholesale markets to refill stocks for the stocked-out SKUs. No distributor or B2B ecommerce company delivered products on the same day. Some distributors took even more than a week for delivery.

We volunteered a few times to go to wholesale market to procure the products for a store operator on his behalf. And after helping him on this for a few times, we imagined that we could deliver products to all stores and create a business out of it. We found that Corner stores lose ~15% sales because of stock outs. This is because of lack of digital billing system and tracking of inventory, shortage of space to put excess inventory and lack of working capital. This problem could be solved by multiple small warehouses in a city with optimized SKU assortment, inventory, and logistics. That is how we decided launch Angadi.

We believe that we are the right team to do this. All 3 of us have a passion for retail and have known one another for around a decade. I have managed a $50 million distribution company with a reach to 100,000 small stores. Abhijit has 10+ years in tech and was the Director of Engineering at a major fintech player, with a strong understanding of credit & loan in retail. Muneeb is a CS grad and has developed multiple products for Retailers and Small Businesses during his career.

What's new about what you're making? What substitutes do people resort to because it doesn't exist yet (or they don't know about it)?

There is no distributor/company in the market that supplies to the stores within the same day, let alone in 2 hours. As of now, the only substitute that the stores have for stocked out products - is to go to the nearby wholesale market/distributor and get the stock replenished by themselves. Else, they suffer sales loss till the time the stock is delivered by a distributor; this is typically between 2 days and 1 week.

Who are your competitors, and who might become competitors? Who do you fear most?

Udaan, Amazon Business and Flipkart B2B, among others, are our competitors. These companies have a slightly different value proposition. They provide the broadest selection at the cheapest prices. We, on the other hand, provide a selection of fast-moving SKUs with fastest delivery.

We fear firms with deep market penetration such as Udaan and Amazon Business. Even though they have evolved as B2B ecommerce firms with a big fulfilment centre per region, it is not impossible for them to add multiple small FCs within in the region/city to cut down on the fulfilment time.

What do you understand about your business that other companies in it just don't get?

- For 85% of all procurement, the corner stores would check with all the suppliers - Open Market Distributors, Udaan, Amazon Business, Flipkart Wholesale etc before making the order. The procurement decision is then made by the retailers after considering just one factor – who gives lowest price? There is almost zero loyalty for retailers to any supplier here.

- The remaining 15% procurement kicks in, when there is a stockout. For this, stores do either of below:

Roughly ~50% Corner Store owners rush to a nearby wholesale markets to get the products in cash.

And the remaining half decide to suffer sales loss for next 2 days. They make an order in any of the apps/distributors and get the orders in due time albeit suffering the loss in sales (and more importantly customer satisfaction) in the interim period.

- The procurement decision for this “15%” is unique. Retailers are willing to go through the inconvenience, pay in cash for the order and in a few cases willing to pay a small premium for some products. Almost all the companies focus on “85%” market and there is no one that is solving the “15%” problem.

- This “15%” procurement is done for FMCG products. These products have relatively higher margin compared to commodities (sacks of rice, sugar, wheat etc) that retailers plan and purchase.

- The order size of B2C consumer delivery apps such as Instamart (of Swiggy), Flipkart Quick and Amazon Fresh is ~ $6. Our AOV is ~ $65 that could be achieved at the same SKU collection in the warehouse and fulfilled at almost the same delivery expense. And there is more opportunity to become a sole supplier of our valuable customers in due time.

How do or will you make money? How much could you make?

We make money from the margin of the goods that we sell to the corner stores. As of now, we are keeping this as an inventory model with stock in the partner warehouses.

Small stores account for ~90% of total Indian grocery market of $ 800 billion. Our addressable market size is 15% of it – $120 billion dollars. Our plan is to onboard around 1 million retailers by 2025. At an average order size of $6,500 dollars per retailer per year – we could reach a revenue of $6.5 billion.

How will you get users? If your idea is the type that faces a chicken-and-egg problem in the sense that it won't be attractive to users till it has a lot of users (e.g. a marketplace, a dating site, an ad network), how will you overcome that?

We have grown to 100+ users as now. 60+ stores were onboarded by meeting and signing up them when they visited Metro CashNCarry for their purchases. We offered them the same price as that of Metro at zero delivery fees. The rest 40 were added by these customers through referrals. All 100 stores are within a locality of 3 km radius.

It is evident that a large fraction of small store operators would require 1-1 onboarding to start using B2B ecommerce apps. Hence, our plan is to grow users through a mix of 1-1 onboarding, referral campaigns and tie up with bookkeeping apps with high penetration to add more users. We do not have a chicken-and-egg problem.

Equity

Have you incorporated, or formed any legal entity (like an LLC) yet?

Yes

What kind of entity and in what state or country was the entity formed?

Private Limited Company

Please describe the breakdown of the equity ownership in percentages among the founders, employees and any other stockholders. If there are multiple founders, be sure to give the equity ownership of each founder.

We have split equally (33.33% each)

Please provide any other relevant information about the structure or formation of the company.

NA

Legal

Are any of the founders covered by noncompetes or intellectual property agreements that overlap with your project? If so, please explain.

No

Who writes code, or does other technical work on your product? Was any of it done by a non-founder? Please explain.

Both Abhijit and Muneeb write the code.

Is there anything else we should know about your company?

NA

Others

If you had any other ideas you considered applying with, please list them. One may be something we've been waiting for. Often when we fund people it's to do something they list here and not in the main application.

SMB investment marketplace - it is extremely difficult for a small business in India to raise equity investment. Also, individuals with dispensable income are unable to invest in small businesses because of lack of information. We intend solve this problem by resolving this information asymmetry and bringing together small to businesses and small investors.

Please tell us something surprising or amusing that one of you has discovered.

In my eleventh grade, I (Jeff) used to toy with various equations in physics. Out of the blue, I decided to equate the RHS of Einstein's mass energy equivalence (E = mc2) and Plank's equation (E=hv). I ended up getting an equation: λ = h/mc. Without knowing much on what the equation would mean, I thought that it connected mass and wavelength in some way.

Just a few months later, I ended up realizing in 12th grade that this is actually the de Broglie's equation on wave particle duality and the equation was derived in pretty much the same way. Although, it meant that I wasn't the first discoverer of wave particle duality, I did invariably come up with the concept unbeknownst to me that this is something that all physicists knew for many years. A discovery that I'm still proud of :)

Curious

What convinced you to apply to Y Combinator? Did someone encourage you to apply?

YC is the ideal next step for us use the exposure and knowledge that we could get from the program to scale our product and make our startup a success.

We have been following YC podcasts and have a pretty good understanding of the program and how it will help us to succeed.

How did you hear about Y Combinator?

We have been following YC Podcasts/Hacker News for quite some time.

Company

Describe what your company does in 50 characters or less.

Our 2-hr supply prevents stockouts at small stores.

What is your company going to make? Please describe your product and what it does or will do.

We are building a platform for Corner Stores to search and order SKUs that are stocked-out at the time and get them delivered in <2 hours. It works on an asset light model with partner warehouses and partner logistics. Our tools would optimize SKU assortment, warehousing, and logistics. Our product will help in preventing the 15% sales loss that corner stores suffer due to stock outs.

Where do you live now, and where would the company be based after YC?

Bangalore, India

Founders

Please tell us about an interesting project, preferably outside of class or work, that two or more of you created together. Include urls if possible.

We decided to start-up together after one of us - Abhijit decided to solve a crucial problem that he faced during his first job in a big government power company.

At the time, the company was using archaic methods to layout the expansion plan of new transmission lines across multiple regions. They brought together data from multiple tools such as AutoCAD, Excel sheets, Garmin GPS, and Google Earth geolocation data, which were painstakingly collected through ground surveys. No application was available that could do interoperability of these tools. This had to be done manually by copying and pasting from one tool to another. On top of it, google APIs were available to get the elevation data along a line.

Observing this opportunity, Abhijit roped in Muneeb and created a desktop application that helped in interoperability of these tools and extraction of elevation data. A downloadable product with a licensing fee was launched. After realizing that the product could be also sold to construction industry, I joined the firm in 2014.We sold the product to 10+ land survey firms, generating a total revenue of 1m INR (US $15k).

We could not scale further as there were only a handful of power and construction firms in India and many big ones had internally developed tools that they were not willing to move away from.

How long have the founders known one another and how did you meet? Have any of the founders not met in person?

We did our undergrad in engineering in the same university and graduated together. We know one another for around a decade after first meeting in our college dorm.

How many founders are on the team?

3

Category

Which category best applies to your company?

Retail

Progress

How far along are you?

We have launched the product. We have 100 paying customers as of now and we get 40 orders per day. This is in just a single locality in Bangalore. As of now, we are not operating warehouses. As and when we get the orders, our team members who would be at the nearby Metro Cash n Carry, procure the products and hand them over to 3rd party logistics riders for them to deliver. The current average order value is ~65 USD and cost of fulfilment is ~1.2 USD.

How long have each of you been working on this? How much of that has been full-time? Please explain.

We have been working on tools for Corner Stores since Dec’20 and pivoted to this product in May’21. Two of us are working full time on this since then - 2.5 months. Abhijith has started full time from June end.

Are people using your product?

Yes

How many active users or customers do you have? If you have some particularly valuable customers, who are they? If you're building hardware, how many units have you shipped?

We have 100+ customers all located in and around Whitefield, Bangalore.

Our valuable customers are the ones who do >4 orders per week in the platform. The AOV is ~100 USD for these customers. The good thing about these customers is that they have started using our platform for regular procurement that are outside of stocked out SKUs.

Do you have revenue?

Yes

We're interested in your revenue over the last several months. (Not cumulative and not GMV).

  • What was your revenue in June? $20,000

  • What was your revenue in May? $450

  • What was your revenue in April? $

  • What was your revenue in March? $0

  • What was your revenue in February? $0

  • What was your revenue in January? $0

Anything else you would like us to know regarding your revenue or growth rate?

We are growing at a tremendous pace, and we are set to reach USD 50k in revenue in July’21. Our model is hyperlocal in nature. This growth has been achieved by operating in just a locality of Bangalore. We are planning to add more localities in the city and reach 5,000 customers by end of 2021 and reach a monthly revenue of ~$ 1 million per month.

If you are applying with the same idea as a previous batch, did anything change? If you applied with a different idea, why did you pivot and what did you learn from the last idea?

We pivoted. Our first product - ClearBook was a bookkeeping android app for the small stores to accurately track profit and cash in hand. We grew this app to 5,000 downloads and 200 DAU with zero marketing spend.

However, after spending time with around 200+ customers of ClearBook in Bangalore, we understood that frequent stock-outs are a bigger problem for the stores. This leads to revenue loss and at times, even customer churn. Although this problem is more operationally complex to solve, it is a bigger pain point for them, and the solution is also monetizable from day 1.

If you have already participated or committed to participate in an incubator, "accelerator" or "pre-accelerator" program, please tell us about it.

Na

Idea

Why did you pick this idea to work on? Do you have domain expertise in this area? How do you know people need what you're making?

In 2018, as an investment to get additional income, all three of us with a couple of others, invested in a pharmacy store in Bangalore. As we ran into many bookkeeping problems in the store, Muneeb created a simple android app for the store staff to track daily revenue and expenses. The app - ClearBook was published in Play Store, grew to 5,000 downloads and 200 DAU with zero marketing spend.

This made us to spend time with around 100+ corner stores (who were ClearBook customers) in Bangalore. We noticed that almost all of them ran out of stocks of a few SKUs almost every day. In multiple times per week, we could see the store operators rushing to nearby wholesale markets to refill stocks for the stocked-out SKUs. No distributor or B2B ecommerce company delivered products on the same day. Some distributors took even more than a week for delivery.

We volunteered a few times to go to wholesale market to procure the products for a store operator on his behalf. And after helping him on this for a few times, we imagined that we could deliver products to all stores and create a business out of it. We found that Corner stores lose ~15% sales because of stock outs. This is because of lack of digital billing system and tracking of inventory, shortage of space to put excess inventory and lack of working capital. This problem could be solved by multiple small warehouses in a city with optimized SKU assortment, inventory, and logistics. That is how we decided launch Angadi.

We believe that we are the right team to do this. All 3 of us have a passion for retail and have known one another for around a decade. I have managed a $50 million distribution company with a reach to 100,000 small stores. Abhijit has 10+ years in tech and was the Director of Engineering at a major fintech player, with a strong understanding of credit & loan in retail. Muneeb is a CS grad and has developed multiple products for Retailers and Small Businesses during his career.

What's new about what you're making? What substitutes do people resort to because it doesn't exist yet (or they don't know about it)?

There is no distributor/company in the market that supplies to the stores within the same day, let alone in 2 hours. As of now, the only substitute that the stores have for stocked out products - is to go to the nearby wholesale market/distributor and get the stock replenished by themselves. Else, they suffer sales loss till the time the stock is delivered by a distributor; this is typically between 2 days and 1 week.

Who are your competitors, and who might become competitors? Who do you fear most?

Udaan, Amazon Business and Flipkart B2B, among others, are our competitors. These companies have a slightly different value proposition. They provide the broadest selection at the cheapest prices. We, on the other hand, provide a selection of fast-moving SKUs with fastest delivery.

We fear firms with deep market penetration such as Udaan and Amazon Business. Even though they have evolved as B2B ecommerce firms with a big fulfilment centre per region, it is not impossible for them to add multiple small FCs within in the region/city to cut down on the fulfilment time.

What do you understand about your business that other companies in it just don't get?

- For 85% of all procurement, the corner stores would check with all the suppliers - Open Market Distributors, Udaan, Amazon Business, Flipkart Wholesale etc before making the order. The procurement decision is then made by the retailers after considering just one factor – who gives lowest price? There is almost zero loyalty for retailers to any supplier here.

- The remaining 15% procurement kicks in, when there is a stockout. For this, stores do either of below:

Roughly ~50% Corner Store owners rush to a nearby wholesale markets to get the products in cash.

And the remaining half decide to suffer sales loss for next 2 days. They make an order in any of the apps/distributors and get the orders in due time albeit suffering the loss in sales (and more importantly customer satisfaction) in the interim period.

- The procurement decision for this “15%” is unique. Retailers are willing to go through the inconvenience, pay in cash for the order and in a few cases willing to pay a small premium for some products. Almost all the companies focus on “85%” market and there is no one that is solving the “15%” problem.

- This “15%” procurement is done for FMCG products. These products have relatively higher margin compared to commodities (sacks of rice, sugar, wheat etc) that retailers plan and purchase.

- The order size of B2C consumer delivery apps such as Instamart (of Swiggy), Flipkart Quick and Amazon Fresh is ~ $6. Our AOV is ~ $65 that could be achieved at the same SKU collection in the warehouse and fulfilled at almost the same delivery expense. And there is more opportunity to become a sole supplier of our valuable customers in due time.

How do or will you make money? How much could you make?

We make money from the margin of the goods that we sell to the corner stores. As of now, we are keeping this as an inventory model with stock in the partner warehouses.

Small stores account for ~90% of total Indian grocery market of $ 800 billion. Our addressable market size is 15% of it – $120 billion dollars. Our plan is to onboard around 1 million retailers by 2025. At an average order size of $6,500 dollars per retailer per year – we could reach a revenue of $6.5 billion.

How will you get users? If your idea is the type that faces a chicken-and-egg problem in the sense that it won't be attractive to users till it has a lot of users (e.g. a marketplace, a dating site, an ad network), how will you overcome that?

We have grown to 100+ users as now. 60+ stores were onboarded by meeting and signing up them when they visited Metro CashNCarry for their purchases. We offered them the same price as that of Metro at zero delivery fees. The rest 40 were added by these customers through referrals. All 100 stores are within a locality of 3 km radius.

It is evident that a large fraction of small store operators would require 1-1 onboarding to start using B2B ecommerce apps. Hence, our plan is to grow users through a mix of 1-1 onboarding, referral campaigns and tie up with bookkeeping apps with high penetration to add more users. We do not have a chicken-and-egg problem.

Equity

Have you incorporated, or formed any legal entity (like an LLC) yet?

Yes

What kind of entity and in what state or country was the entity formed?

Private Limited Company

Please describe the breakdown of the equity ownership in percentages among the founders, employees and any other stockholders. If there are multiple founders, be sure to give the equity ownership of each founder.

We have split equally (33.33% each)

Please provide any other relevant information about the structure or formation of the company.

NA

Legal

Are any of the founders covered by noncompetes or intellectual property agreements that overlap with your project? If so, please explain.

No

Who writes code, or does other technical work on your product? Was any of it done by a non-founder? Please explain.

Both Abhijit and Muneeb write the code.

Is there anything else we should know about your company?

NA

Others

If you had any other ideas you considered applying with, please list them. One may be something we've been waiting for. Often when we fund people it's to do something they list here and not in the main application.

SMB investment marketplace - it is extremely difficult for a small business in India to raise equity investment. Also, individuals with dispensable income are unable to invest in small businesses because of lack of information. We intend solve this problem by resolving this information asymmetry and bringing together small to businesses and small investors.

Please tell us something surprising or amusing that one of you has discovered.

In my eleventh grade, I (Jeff) used to toy with various equations in physics. Out of the blue, I decided to equate the RHS of Einstein's mass energy equivalence (E = mc2) and Plank's equation (E=hv). I ended up getting an equation: λ = h/mc. Without knowing much on what the equation would mean, I thought that it connected mass and wavelength in some way.

Just a few months later, I ended up realizing in 12th grade that this is actually the de Broglie's equation on wave particle duality and the equation was derived in pretty much the same way. Although, it meant that I wasn't the first discoverer of wave particle duality, I did invariably come up with the concept unbeknownst to me that this is something that all physicists knew for many years. A discovery that I'm still proud of :)

Curious

What convinced you to apply to Y Combinator? Did someone encourage you to apply?

YC is the ideal next step for us use the exposure and knowledge that we could get from the program to scale our product and make our startup a success.

We have been following YC podcasts and have a pretty good understanding of the program and how it will help us to succeed.

How did you hear about Y Combinator?

We have been following YC Podcasts/Hacker News for quite some time.

See Why

Feedback

Feedback

Executive Summary:

The YC application from Parobyte Technologies outlines a promising business model revolving around quick supply replenishment for corner stores, aiming to resolve the frequent stock-outs that lead to sales loss. The company is already operational in Bangalore with 100 paying customers and displays a rapid growth trajectory. The application details the product, market strategy, the team's background, and financial projections. However, improvements can be made in articulating unique value propositions, detailing market penetration strategies, and showcasing a deeper analysis of financials and scalability.

Investment Thesis Relevance:

The startup's core offering aligns with YC's interest in scalable, tech-driven solutions addressing sizable market inefficiencies. Parobyte's technology roots and practical approach to a clear retail problem show potential. They should emphasize their tech-driven asset-light model and superior logistics technology to carve out a niche in a competitive market. Detailed specifics about their technology use could be more convincing to YC's tech-centric investment thesis.

Market Understanding and Strategy:

The application suggests a deep understanding of the corner store market and supply challenges. The founders leverage personal experiences to target a significant pain point. However, the competitive landscape analysis feels superficial. Parobyte should focus on clearly articulating what truly sets them apart from large players that could quickly replicate their delivery model. Expressing a comprehensible go-to-market strategy for different locales and how they plan to tackle regulatory challenges can enhance their strategy narrative.

Business Model Evaluation:

The business model appears sustainable with a clear revenue stream from product margins. Scaling poses potential risks, including warehousing costs and logistics efficiency at larger scales. The projection of reaching $6.5 billion in revenue by 2025 may be overly optimistic without clear steps on achieving this growth. A step-by-step growth plan detailing how they will expand beyond the Bangalore market would benefit the application.

Team Competency and Dynamics:

The founding team's decade of acquaintance and complementary skillsets form a robust base. However, the narrative around prior projects and domain expertise lacks persuasive details on their ability to scale a retail logistics platform. They should elaborate on specific experiences and skills that equip them to tackle the operational complexities of rapid logistics.

Operational Efficiency and Milestone Achievement:

The startup is operationally active, with 100 customers and growing. Yet, the reliance on manual processes for order fulfilment (team members purchasing and delivering stock) is a significant bottleneck for scaling. They should discuss strategic plans to automate and streamline operations as they scale, including potential technology or personnel investments.

Use of Language:

The application is mostly clear and free of jargon, effectively communicating the essence of the startup. However, there are points where the narrative could be more focused. Any technical descriptions should be articulated in a way that showcases the technological advantage they provide. Clarifying acronyms (like SKU) could improve accessibility for readers unfamiliar with retail terminology.

Financial Health and Projections:

The financial projections display an aggressive growth plan. Revenue growth from $0 to $50,000 in six months shows potential but requires a more detailed and realistic projection of future growth. The application should address potential capital requirements for scaling, the risk associated with their inventory model, and how they will manage cash flow as they expand.

Constructive Criticism and Advice:

  1. Define and emphasize the unique value propositions compared to competitors.

  2. Present a more thorough competitive analysis and strategy to retain competitive edge.

  3. Furnish a stepwise growth plan showing scalability beyond the current market.

  4. Elaborate on technological applications and efficiencies that the product will leverage.

  5. Improve the depth of financial analysis and present well-founded projections with assumptions.

  6. Automate and streamline operations for scalability, include plans for future technological investments.

Final Thoughts:

Parobyte Technologies has identified a real problem and is delivering a solution with shown traction. They have strong potential but must address the outlined concerns in their YC application to effectively display their business's ability to scale and sustainably compete. Concrete details on their operational plans, competitive strategy, and financial handling will be crucial to increasing their chance for a successful YC application.


Executive Summary:

The YC application from Parobyte Technologies outlines a promising business model revolving around quick supply replenishment for corner stores, aiming to resolve the frequent stock-outs that lead to sales loss. The company is already operational in Bangalore with 100 paying customers and displays a rapid growth trajectory. The application details the product, market strategy, the team's background, and financial projections. However, improvements can be made in articulating unique value propositions, detailing market penetration strategies, and showcasing a deeper analysis of financials and scalability.

Investment Thesis Relevance:

The startup's core offering aligns with YC's interest in scalable, tech-driven solutions addressing sizable market inefficiencies. Parobyte's technology roots and practical approach to a clear retail problem show potential. They should emphasize their tech-driven asset-light model and superior logistics technology to carve out a niche in a competitive market. Detailed specifics about their technology use could be more convincing to YC's tech-centric investment thesis.

Market Understanding and Strategy:

The application suggests a deep understanding of the corner store market and supply challenges. The founders leverage personal experiences to target a significant pain point. However, the competitive landscape analysis feels superficial. Parobyte should focus on clearly articulating what truly sets them apart from large players that could quickly replicate their delivery model. Expressing a comprehensible go-to-market strategy for different locales and how they plan to tackle regulatory challenges can enhance their strategy narrative.

Business Model Evaluation:

The business model appears sustainable with a clear revenue stream from product margins. Scaling poses potential risks, including warehousing costs and logistics efficiency at larger scales. The projection of reaching $6.5 billion in revenue by 2025 may be overly optimistic without clear steps on achieving this growth. A step-by-step growth plan detailing how they will expand beyond the Bangalore market would benefit the application.

Team Competency and Dynamics:

The founding team's decade of acquaintance and complementary skillsets form a robust base. However, the narrative around prior projects and domain expertise lacks persuasive details on their ability to scale a retail logistics platform. They should elaborate on specific experiences and skills that equip them to tackle the operational complexities of rapid logistics.

Operational Efficiency and Milestone Achievement:

The startup is operationally active, with 100 customers and growing. Yet, the reliance on manual processes for order fulfilment (team members purchasing and delivering stock) is a significant bottleneck for scaling. They should discuss strategic plans to automate and streamline operations as they scale, including potential technology or personnel investments.

Use of Language:

The application is mostly clear and free of jargon, effectively communicating the essence of the startup. However, there are points where the narrative could be more focused. Any technical descriptions should be articulated in a way that showcases the technological advantage they provide. Clarifying acronyms (like SKU) could improve accessibility for readers unfamiliar with retail terminology.

Financial Health and Projections:

The financial projections display an aggressive growth plan. Revenue growth from $0 to $50,000 in six months shows potential but requires a more detailed and realistic projection of future growth. The application should address potential capital requirements for scaling, the risk associated with their inventory model, and how they will manage cash flow as they expand.

Constructive Criticism and Advice:

  1. Define and emphasize the unique value propositions compared to competitors.

  2. Present a more thorough competitive analysis and strategy to retain competitive edge.

  3. Furnish a stepwise growth plan showing scalability beyond the current market.

  4. Elaborate on technological applications and efficiencies that the product will leverage.

  5. Improve the depth of financial analysis and present well-founded projections with assumptions.

  6. Automate and streamline operations for scalability, include plans for future technological investments.

Final Thoughts:

Parobyte Technologies has identified a real problem and is delivering a solution with shown traction. They have strong potential but must address the outlined concerns in their YC application to effectively display their business's ability to scale and sustainably compete. Concrete details on their operational plans, competitive strategy, and financial handling will be crucial to increasing their chance for a successful YC application.


Executive Summary:

The YC application from Parobyte Technologies outlines a promising business model revolving around quick supply replenishment for corner stores, aiming to resolve the frequent stock-outs that lead to sales loss. The company is already operational in Bangalore with 100 paying customers and displays a rapid growth trajectory. The application details the product, market strategy, the team's background, and financial projections. However, improvements can be made in articulating unique value propositions, detailing market penetration strategies, and showcasing a deeper analysis of financials and scalability.

Investment Thesis Relevance:

The startup's core offering aligns with YC's interest in scalable, tech-driven solutions addressing sizable market inefficiencies. Parobyte's technology roots and practical approach to a clear retail problem show potential. They should emphasize their tech-driven asset-light model and superior logistics technology to carve out a niche in a competitive market. Detailed specifics about their technology use could be more convincing to YC's tech-centric investment thesis.

Market Understanding and Strategy:

The application suggests a deep understanding of the corner store market and supply challenges. The founders leverage personal experiences to target a significant pain point. However, the competitive landscape analysis feels superficial. Parobyte should focus on clearly articulating what truly sets them apart from large players that could quickly replicate their delivery model. Expressing a comprehensible go-to-market strategy for different locales and how they plan to tackle regulatory challenges can enhance their strategy narrative.

Business Model Evaluation:

The business model appears sustainable with a clear revenue stream from product margins. Scaling poses potential risks, including warehousing costs and logistics efficiency at larger scales. The projection of reaching $6.5 billion in revenue by 2025 may be overly optimistic without clear steps on achieving this growth. A step-by-step growth plan detailing how they will expand beyond the Bangalore market would benefit the application.

Team Competency and Dynamics:

The founding team's decade of acquaintance and complementary skillsets form a robust base. However, the narrative around prior projects and domain expertise lacks persuasive details on their ability to scale a retail logistics platform. They should elaborate on specific experiences and skills that equip them to tackle the operational complexities of rapid logistics.

Operational Efficiency and Milestone Achievement:

The startup is operationally active, with 100 customers and growing. Yet, the reliance on manual processes for order fulfilment (team members purchasing and delivering stock) is a significant bottleneck for scaling. They should discuss strategic plans to automate and streamline operations as they scale, including potential technology or personnel investments.

Use of Language:

The application is mostly clear and free of jargon, effectively communicating the essence of the startup. However, there are points where the narrative could be more focused. Any technical descriptions should be articulated in a way that showcases the technological advantage they provide. Clarifying acronyms (like SKU) could improve accessibility for readers unfamiliar with retail terminology.

Financial Health and Projections:

The financial projections display an aggressive growth plan. Revenue growth from $0 to $50,000 in six months shows potential but requires a more detailed and realistic projection of future growth. The application should address potential capital requirements for scaling, the risk associated with their inventory model, and how they will manage cash flow as they expand.

Constructive Criticism and Advice:

  1. Define and emphasize the unique value propositions compared to competitors.

  2. Present a more thorough competitive analysis and strategy to retain competitive edge.

  3. Furnish a stepwise growth plan showing scalability beyond the current market.

  4. Elaborate on technological applications and efficiencies that the product will leverage.

  5. Improve the depth of financial analysis and present well-founded projections with assumptions.

  6. Automate and streamline operations for scalability, include plans for future technological investments.

Final Thoughts:

Parobyte Technologies has identified a real problem and is delivering a solution with shown traction. They have strong potential but must address the outlined concerns in their YC application to effectively display their business's ability to scale and sustainably compete. Concrete details on their operational plans, competitive strategy, and financial handling will be crucial to increasing their chance for a successful YC application.